Three ways to earn steady returns
A fixed deposit (FD) locks a lump sum with a bank for a fixed period at a rate agreed on the day you invest. A recurring deposit (RD) does the same for a fixed amount paid every month. A debt mutual fund pools money into bonds, government securities and money-market instruments; it has no fixed rate, and its value moves with interest rates and the credit quality of what it holds.
All three suit money you want to keep relatively safe, but they differ on certainty, tax, insurance and how quickly you can get your money back.
At a glance
| Fixed deposit | Recurring deposit | Debt mutual fund | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you invest | One lump sum | Fixed amount every month | Lump sum or SIP |
| Return | Fixed when you book | Fixed when you open | Not fixed; moves with bond prices |
| Deposit insurance | DICGC, up to ₹5 lakh per bank | DICGC, up to ₹5 lakh per bank | None |
| Tax on returns | Slab rate, every year as interest accrues | Slab rate, every year as interest accrues | Slab rate, only when you redeem* |
| TDS | Yes, above the yearly threshold | Yes, above the yearly threshold | No TDS on gains for residents |
| Leaving early | Penalty, often 0.5–1% of the rate | Penalty, often 0.5–1% of the rate | Exit load in some funds, usually only for an initial period |
| Best for | A known amount on a known date | Building savings from monthly income | Parking money flexibly, larger sums |
* For debt fund units bought on or after 1 April 2023. Units bought earlier and held for more than two years are taxed at 12.5% on the gain.
Returns: locked in or variable
With an FD you know the result on day one. ₹5 lakh at 7% for three years, compounded quarterly, matures at about ₹6.16 lakh.
A debt fund’s return depends on what happens to interest rates while you hold it. When rates fall, bond prices rise and debt funds can earn more than the FD rate; when rates rise, prices fall and returns can dip, sometimes below zero for funds holding long-dated bonds. Liquid, overnight and short-duration funds move far less than long-duration and gilt funds.
An RD earns the same kind of rate as an FD, but each instalment is invested for a shorter time, so the interest on the total you put in is lower. It is a savings habit, not a higher-return product.
Tax: what changed in 2023
Debt funds used to have a large tax advantage: gains on units held for more than three years were taxed at 20% after indexation for inflation, often well below the investor’s slab rate. From 1 April 2023, gains on newly bought debt fund units are added to your income and taxed at your slab rate, however long you hold them, the same rate as FD interest.
One difference remains: timing. FD and RD interest is taxable every year as it accrues, even if you receive it only at maturity. Debt fund gains are taxed only when you redeem, so the money you would have paid in tax keeps earning in the meantime, and you can choose to redeem in a year when your income is lower.
Safety and getting your money back
- Bank FDs and RDs are insured by DICGC up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank, covering principal and interest together. Above that, spread deposits across banks.
- Debt funds are not insured. Their risks are credit risk, if a borrower defaults, and interest-rate risk. Funds that hold government securities or top-rated, short-term paper carry the least of both.
- FDs and RDs can be broken early with a penalty on the rate. Most debt funds pay out the business day after you redeem, and many have no exit load at all.
Which one to choose
- Choose an FD when you need a known amount on a known date, such as a fee or a down payment, or if you want guaranteed income. Senior citizens usually get about 0.5% more.
- Choose an RD to build a fixed sum from your monthly income, for example over a year or two.
- Consider a liquid or short-duration debt fund for money you may need at short notice, for amounts above the ₹5 lakh insurance cover, or if you are in a high tax bracket and want to defer the tax.
- For tax-free returns with government backing, compare PPF and, for a daughter, Sukanya Samriddhi; for retirees, the Senior Citizens Savings Scheme.
Frequently asked questions
Are debt funds safer than FDs?
No. Bank FDs are insured up to ₹5 lakh per bank and have a fixed return. Debt funds are not insured and their value can fall, although funds holding government securities or top-rated short-term paper carry low risk.
Is an RD better than an FD?
For the same total amount, an FD earns more because all the money is invested from the first day. An RD is useful when you are saving from monthly income and do not have a lump sum yet.
How are debt mutual funds taxed now?
Gains on units bought on or after 1 April 2023 are taxed at your slab rate when you redeem, whatever the holding period. Units bought before that date and held for more than two years are taxed at 12.5% on the gain.
Where should I keep my emergency fund?
Many people keep a month or two of expenses in a savings account and the rest in a sweep-in FD or a liquid fund, both of which can be withdrawn within a day.